Book through our site
—up to 10% cheaper
than Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From513US$ /night
Check-in
26Oct2025Select date
Check-out
27Oct2025Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Hotel

Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040

Amenities

Sugar Pie Suite offers spacious accommodations designed for relaxation with easy access to local attractions. Guests can enjoy the complimentary beach gear, which includes bikes, snorkel gear, and beach chairs. The outdoor area features a heated swimming pool surrounded by vibrant tropical gardens.

Rooms

This suite includes a well-equipped kitchen, allowing guests to prepare meals at their convenience. The bedroom is outfitted with a king-sized bed, ensuring a restful night's sleep. Additionally, the suite offers a private patio, providing a personal outdoor space for guests to enjoy.

Location

Situated just minutes from the historic Old Town, Sugar Pie Suite is a short distance from popular attractions such as the Southernmost Point Buoy and Duval Street. Nearby activities include snorkeling and sailing, easily accessible via local tour services. The hotel is in proximity to several dining options, showcasing the local cuisine.

Dining

Sugar Pie Suite encourages guests to explore the diverse dining options available in Key West. Local favorites include seafood restaurants and cafes that highlight fresh ingredients. The suite's kitchen allows for in-room dining experiences, should guests prefer to dine privately.

Entertainment

The hotel organizes various local tours that provide guests with insight into the culture and history of Key West. Guests have the opportunity to join fishing charters and sunset cruises for memorable experiences. Free bicycle rentals provide a chance to explore the island at leisure.

Highlights

Location: Minutes from the historic Old Town

Rooms: Spacious accommodations with a well-equipped kitchen

Dining: Local favorites include seafood restaurants

Entertainment: Various local tours and activities available

View all

Select your room type

The hotel provides a selection of rooms—doubles, family rooms, and suites—with perks like free cancellation, breakfast options, and great value deals
Studio
2 persons
19 m² 
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning

Room rates & availability calendar

See the best prices and book your dates today!

Getting around town

Transport options available

City Centre
Key West 2.2 km
Airports
Key West International (EYW) 6.4 km

Amenities & services

Real traveler stories and honest reviews—no glossy ads, just authentic feedback to guide your booking

General

  • No smoking on site
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Pets allowed

Sports & Fitness

  • Water sports
  • Cycling
  • Golf course
  • Fishing

Spa & Leisure

  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Aqua park
  • Garden area

Room features

  • Wi-Fi in rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Patio
  • Tea and coffee facilities
  • Ironing facilities

Bathroom

  • Free toiletries
Show more

Location

Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040
Map view
Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040
Nearby
Square
Mallory Square
580 m
Museum
Truman Little White House
560 m
Aquarium
Key West Aquarium
530 m
Museum
Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum
530 m
511 Caroline St
Curry Mansion
140 m
Event hall
San Carlos Institute Casa Cuba
550 m
Museum
Ripley's Believe It or Not
400 m
Garden
Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden
450 m
Gallery
The Studios of Key West
170 m
Museum
Mel Fisher Maritime Heritage Museum
440 m
Garden
Audubon House and Tropical Gardens
440 m
Mallory Square between Whitehead and Wall sts.
Memorial Sculpture Garden
520 m
Square
Key West-Florida Keys Historical Military Memorial
420 m
Gallery
7 Artists & Friends Gallery
60 m
Gallery
Gallery on Greene
130 m
Church
Saint Paul's Episcopal Church of Key West
370 m
410 Caroline St Between Duval and Whitehead Streets
Key West Pirates Well
240 m
490 Whitehead St
US 1 Mile Marker 0
580 m
534 Fleming St
KEPart Studio-Gallery
320 m
519 Duval St
Peter Lik Gallery Key West
410 m
Restaurants
Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe
250 m
200 Elizabeth St Corner of Greene & Elizabeth Street
Garbo's Grill
280 m
409 Caroline Street
Key West Key Lime Pie Co
220 m
511 Greene St
Shorty's Market
270 m
215 Duval St
Hot Dog Lounge
180 m
corner of Caroline St and Duval St
Paradise Pizza
250 m
503 Greene St
Angelina's Pizzeria
290 m
208 Duval St Ricks & Durty Harrys Complex
Sweet Pete's
260 m
511 Greene St
Fisherman's Cafe
350 m
205 Elizabeth St Unit D
Boardwalk Frozen Custard
320 m
335 Duval St
Looking for early-bird discounts?
Get special discounted rates today!
Check Rates

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.

Inspiration for future getaways

Good Inn alternatives
Check-in
26Oct2025Select date
Check-out
27Oct2025Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room